Men's Mental Health - A Silent Crisis
WE ARE DESIGNED TO FEEL
Our capacity as human beings to grow our emotional depth and intelligence is among the qualities that distinguish human beings from the rest of creation. We are blessed with a complexity of feelings that shape our everyday experiences, and these emotions are essential to recognise, understand and manage. How do we balance hope, fear, anxiety, joy, wonder, guilt and countless other emotions within ourselves, especially when dealing with the challenges life throws at us?
Our beloved Nabi Muhammad (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) was the paragon of emotional intelligence. He r embodied mastery of one's feelings amidst the trials of the world. Yet, despite his example, many men are facing a mental health crisis, and it often happens in silence.
Mental health refers to our emotional, psychological and social wellbeing. It influences how we think, feel, respond and interact with others and life’s challenges. Experiencing stress, sadness or anxiety at times is part of being human, and the lives of the Prophets u remind us that trials, grief and emotional hardship are part of the human experience. Islam teaches us to care for ourselves holistically, nurturing our spiritual, physical and emotional wellbeing while placing our complete trust in Allah.
STIGMA
The stigma surrounding the challenge of men seeking help for social, psychological and spiritual trials has prevented many from speaking out until it's far too late. Men in South Africa are disproportionately represented in several troubling statistics, including suicide, substance abuse, violent crime and untreated mental illness. They are also less likely to admit to their problems and seek help compared to women. But, why?
One of the significant reasons for this is that mental health within the Muslim community is still a largely taboo subject. Within our communities there exists a misconception that if someone is suffering, it suggests that their Iman is weak or that they aren't praying enough. However, Islam places a great emphasis on the holistic nature of human beings, giving due importance to spiritual, physical and psychosocial wellbeing.
Common stigmas include:
“Boys don't cry”
“You're acting like a girl.”
“Strong men swallow their feelings”
Phrases like these are embedded in our everyday language and have permeated through society's layers. These attitudes are sometimes subtle enough that you don't even notice its presence. Ideas such as men not needing emotional support, or the expectation that men should carry every burden alone simply exacerbate the silent suffering.
ROLES
Our society has been acutely enveloped in confusion regarding the roles we are meant to fulfill. Disillusioned amidst societal and cultural expectations, many are lost on how to make sense of it all.
Ibn 'Umar reported that the Prophet Muhammad r said, "All of you are shepherds and each of you is responsible for his flock. A man is the shepherd of the people of his house and he is responsible. A woman is the shepherd of the house of her husband and she is responsible. Each of you is a shepherd and each is responsible for his flock.” (Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 212)
Islam has meticulously outlined the honourable roles of men and women in homes and society; something we should be taking cognisance of and comfort in. Yet, with role shifts and reversals, distorted perceptions and spiritual maladies, men and women appear to be floundering, with many fluctuating from one extreme to the next.
Societies and cultures are divided, and it's an endless tug of war regarding who is right. Should men suppress their emotions to appear strong? Or should they abandon every traditional understanding of masculinity?
It may feel shameful for someone to seek help for mental or social struggles if they have conditioned themselves to bottle up their feelings. Conversely, some may seek validation in unhealthy ways without pursuing meaningful solutions or professional guidance, entrapping themselves in a victim-mindset.
The confusion, the dismantling of roles, restructuring of expectations and distortions have taken us away from the concept of Prophetic masculinity, emotional intelligence and true healing.
Protector. Provider. Maintainer. It takes a lot of hard work to rise to these honourable roles. It also takes mental and emotional strength, thus, don't shy away from reaching out and seeking guidance.
NO MAN IS AN ISLAND
We see in the life of Rasulullah r and the Sahabah y many examples of community spirit and brotherhood. Allah Ta'ala has created this system of interdependence. Human beings were created to support one another, particularly during times of hardship. Talking about our difficulties or seeking comfort is not a sign of weakness, neither is it a sign of diminished masculinity nor weakness in Iman.
After Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) received the first revelation in the Cave of Hira, He (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) went to his wife, Khadija (R) and said, “Cover me! Cover me!” She covered him until his fear was calmed, and after that Rasululllah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) told Khadija (R) everything that had happened and said, “I fear that something may happen to me”. Khadija (R) then comforted him and took Rasulullah (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) to her cousin Waraqah Bin Naufal, to assist him during this tumultuous period.
One of the lessons we learn from the above incident is that it is both natural and important to take comfort and support from our near and dear ones, or from trusted individuals with the capacity to assist.
Mashwara (consultation) is a valued concept within Islam. Allah Ta'ala instructed Nabi Muhammad (Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam) to consult the Sahabah in an incident narrated in the Qur'an: “…and consult with them in conducting matters. Once you make a decision, put your trust in Allah. Surely Allah loves those who trust in Him.” (Surah Ali 'Imran:159)
We should be discerning when seeking advice. Trusted family members, knowledgeable scholars, qualified counsellors, psychologists and medical professionals each have an important role, depending on the nature of the difficulty.
BREAK THE STIGMA
Remember:
You are not a burden
You are not alone
Caring for your mental health allows you to better fulfil your responsibilities towards Allah, yourself and those around you Silence perpetuates denial and suffering
The best of creation were tested, and Allah Ta'ala tests those whom He loves
Allah Ta'ala is greater than your worries
WHAT TO DO IF YOU'RE STRUGGLING
Experiencing persistent sadness, anxiety, overwhelming stress or other mental health difficulties does not make you weak, nor does it mean your Iman is deficient. Just as we seek treatment for physical illness, Islam encourages us to take the appropriate means to care for our emotional and psychological wellbeing while placing our trust in Allah Ta'ala.
If you are struggling, remember that you do not have to carry your burden alone.
Turn to Allah Ta'ala – Strengthen your connection with Him through sincere Dua, Salah, recitation of the Quran and Dhikr. These acts of worship/ Ibadah provide comfort, hope and perspective, reminding us that Allah Ta'ala is always near and fully aware of our struggles.
Speak to someone you trust – Confiding in a spouse, parent, sibling, close friend, Imam or respected mentor can ease the burden of suffering in silence. Sharing your difficulties is not a sign of weakness; rather, it is often the first step towards healing.
Likewise, if someone confides in you, listen with compassion and without judgement. Offer reassurance, encourage them to seek appropriate support where necessary, and remind them that they do not have to face their struggles alone. A listening ear and a kind word can be a means of immense comfort by the will of Allah.
Seek professional help when needed – If your symptoms persist, become overwhelming or begin affecting your daily life, do not hesitate to consult a qualified psychologist, counsellor, psychiatrist or medical practitioner. Seeking support early can often prevent difficulties from becoming more severe. Seeking treatment is not contrary to Tawakkul (placing one's complete trust in Allah), rather it is part of taking the means that Allah has provided.
Be patient with yourself – Healing is often a gradual journey rather than an immediate destination. There may be good days and difficult days, but with sincere effort, support and reliance upon Allah, progress is possible.
Finally, if you or someone you know is experiencing thoughts of self-harm or suicide, seek immmediate assistance from a trusted family member, a qualified healthcare professional or your nearest emergency service. Every life is an Amaanah (trust) from Allah Ta'ala, and no one should face such strikes alone.
Allah Ta'ala reminds us: ” Indeed, with hardship comes ease. Indeed, with hardship comes ease.” (Surah Ash-Sharh: 5-6)
No matter how overwhelming your circumstances may feel, remember that Allah Ta'ala is greater than every hardship. Take the means He has provided, place your trust in Him, and never lose hope in His Infinite Mercy.
Welcome Ngwenya, M., & Olivia Sumbane, G. (2022). The Urgency of Access to Men-Centered Mental Healthcare Services to Address Men's Sensitive Issues in the Communities of South Africa.
Sahih Bukhari 7138, Sahih Muslim 1829